"I'm anti-AI and pro human"


I heard someone say this in a call with writers the other day.

It's understandable to be resentful of large language models (LLMs) when you're a writer and see the market flood with AI generated content.

It can feel discouraging. Especially when you take pride in your craft as a writer.

I totally get it.

However, the stance "anti-AI, pro-human" gives me pause. For one thing, are you sure you're anti-AI? Do you use Google to search information? Do you check the weather? Do you use Netflix or social media and look at their recommended content? Are you aware of how much AI is in our infrastructure?

I'd be genuinely curious if that person truly found a way to avoid AI. I'd be very impressed. At this point, in my eyes, it's unavoidable to do avoid AI.

This "anti" framing concerns me less for what this person says about AI and more for what it says about the direction we're going in as a society. When we organize ourselves by what we're against, we stop being curious. We stop listening to others. And we lose the nuance that's require to navigate this complex landscape.

It's not either or. We can work with AI and be human on purpose. When we embrace the technology with awareness of its pitfalls, we make a choice to take the middle path and get the best of both.

AI can be a huge force amplifier for us. It can help us scale ourselves up in so many incredible ways.

And…it can also lull us into atrophying our skills and outsourcing our authority to yet another entity.

That's why I teach the renaissance approach: intentionally navigating both sides so we maintain our internal capacities and authority.

I'm still navigating all this myself and am glad you're here with me!

Rachel

P.S. — If this resonated, I made something for you. The AI Reality Check helps you develop your own informed perspective on AI. Grab it free here: AI Reality Check.


In case you need a reminder of why you're here — this newsletter exists for people who are done letting outside voices drown out their own. Every issue is about reclaiming your internal authority, in whatever area of life needs it most right now. Glad you're here.

Explore more at ✨ Renaissance Rachel →


Renaissance Rachel

For people who are done letting outside voices — technology, experts, cultural noise — drown out their own. Every issue explores how to reclaim your discernment, your body awareness, and your creative authority across the parts of life that matter most: technology, relationships, wellness, work, and creativity.

Read more from Renaissance Rachel

I finished a book last night that made me mad. And I mean that in the best possible way. Yesteryear by Caro Claire Burke had a premise I couldn't resist: a tradwife influencer forced to actually live in 1855. As someone who believes the past holds real wisdom worth recovering, I was curious. I wanted to see an author take that question seriously. She didn't. And I've been sitting with why that bothers me so much. I also wasn't expecting to end up disappointed in Anne Hathaway. You don't need...

Last week, I talked about my excitement to try out building with Claude. I built two full apps that actually work! (If you're interested in trying them out, let me know, would love feedback) And I mentioned at the end how my neck hurt. Well, it got worse. I spent that whole weekend resting because it literally hurt to move my head. And on top of that, I had my monthly reminder to slow down — the kind that comes whether you're ready for it or not. I find that when I actually honor that time in...

Heyo, I thought I might share some rougher thoughts and experiences with you. The more I work with LLMs, the more I see the signatures of LLM-speak in the posts and content I read. I use it, obviously, and I'm finding it so refreshing to human-written stuff. Both are true! And I do believe we can create beautifully human things with AI assistance. I use different AI tools for different purposes. I use both ChatGPT and Claude. And I always have. I've found that they're great at different...